A new roof does not automatically mean new gutters.
Assess the gutters separately. Sound gutters may stay in place with protection, while other projects require removal or replacement. Their condition, position and the roof-edge work matter. GAF's guidance explains why removal is a project-specific decision—not a requirement for every reroof.
Before approving a North Texas reroof, ask one extra question: what will happen to the gutters? “New roof” should not leave you guessing whether existing gutters stay, get reinstalled or are replaced.
Should you keep, repair or replace the existing gutters?
Ask for an assessment of the gutter system, not an automatic add-on. Have the contractor distinguish a maintenance or localized problem from a system that needs replacement. These questions help make that conversation specific:
Keeping or repairing
- Can the existing gutters remain securely attached and drain correctly?
- Can a particular problem be corrected without replacing the other runs?
- How will retained gutters be protected during tear-off?
Considering replacement
- Which sections are damaged, and what makes repair unsuitable?
- Does the proposed system address existing overflow or drainage concerns?
- Are downspouts and their discharge locations included?
Do not judge only by color or age. Show the contractor where you have noticed leaks, separation, overflow or water collecting beside the house. Our gutters and downspouts service connects the proposed work to the property's drainage needs.
Do the gutters have to come off before the roof is replaced?
Not on every roof. GAF notes that gutters can sometimes remain, but removal may protect them or provide access for roof-edge work and fascia inspection. Fascia is the board along the roof edge that commonly supports gutters. Review the removal considerations.
Ask the estimate to name the intended outcome: keep in place, remove and reinstall suitable existing components, or remove and replace. Those are different scopes; “remove gutters” alone does not tell you which one you are buying.
When new gutters are part of the job, GAF describes fitting them after the roofing work. Confirm the actual sequence and any separate visit in writing. Our roof replacement timeline guide distinguishes roof-installation days from completion of the full project.
What matters besides the gutter itself?
The connection at the roof edge
Drip edge is metal flashing at the roof perimeter. At a guttered eave, it should direct water into the gutter rather than behind it. The Building America Solution Center explains this connection and why missing flashing can leave wood exposed to water.
Ask who will check that detail and the supporting fascia before the gutter work is closed out. Damage discovered there should be documented and discussed; it should not be assumed from a ground-level photo.
Capacity, downspouts and the discharge point
The Building America gutter guidance emphasizes sizing the gutters and downspouts for the water load and directing runoff away from the home. A larger gutter alone is not a complete plan: outlets, downspout placement and the route at ground level also matter.
Ask the contractor to explain where the water will go after it leaves each downspout. The answer should suit the roof and the site—not be a blanket promise that one gutter size works for every home.
What should a roof-and-gutter estimate explain?
The Texas Department of Insurance recommends written bids that identify the proposed work and materials. For a combined roof-and-gutter project, use these checkpoints to compare the scope:
- What stays and what goesIdentify the gutter runs and downspouts to keep, repair, remove and reinstall, or replace. Clarify disposal of removed materials.
- Materials and drainage detailsConfirm the proposed material, profile, size, color, outlets and downspout discharge locations. Ask what any gutter-guard work includes or excludes.
- Roof-edge work and discoveriesAgree who handles flashing and fascia, and how additional damage will be photographed, priced and approved.
- Schedule and closeoutConfirm separate visits, interim runoff arrangements, cleanup, the final drainage check and the written warranty terms for each part of the job.
These are questions to resolve with your contractor, not a promise that every item is included in every estimate. Compare them alongside the roofing scope described on our roof replacement page.
What did the Sherman and Denison projects include?
Both jobs below included new seamless gutters and downspouts after the reroof. They show completed scopes—not a rule that every roof replacement requires new gutters.
Roofing, decking repairs and gutter work.
The crew removed the roofing, gutters and three layers of felt, then repaired water-damaged plywood. Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration shingles in Estate Gray were installed, followed by new seamless gutters and downspouts.
See the Sherman project →
Driftwood shingles, then seamless gutters.
This hail-damage insurance reroof included removal of the existing roof and gutters. The homeowner received Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration shingles in Driftwood, with new seamless gutters and downspouts installed afterward.
See the Denison project →Common roof-and-gutter questions.
Does a roof-replacement price automatically include gutters?
Do not assume it does. Ask the written proposal to state whether gutters, downspouts, removal, reinstallation and disposal are included. Have missing items clarified before you approve the work.
Must the roof and gutters be finished on the same day?
No. For example, the documented Pottsboro reroof had gutters installed on a separate day. Confirm the full schedule for your own job rather than treating the roof's finish date as completion of every item.
What should happen to gutters that stay in place?
Agree how they will be protected and checked afterward. GAF recommends clearing roofing debris and checking function when the roof is finished. Clarify whether any pre-existing blockage or unrelated cleaning is outside the scope.
Roof-edge guidance and documented projects.
General guidance comes from the sources below. Sherman, Denison and Pottsboro job details come from the linked American Roofing & Construction project records. The checklists are planning questions, not a substitute for a site assessment.
Plan the roof and drainage work together.
Tell us about the roofing problem and any gutter concerns you have noticed. American Roofing & Construction offers free roof inspections and gutter and downspout services across its North Texas and Texoma service area.
Request a Free Inspection